The finest GPS trackers for cats and canines

Jake Levins February 23, 2020 34 No Comments


Why it’s best to belief us

I’ve been a canine proprietor for many of my life, from rising up with mutts to adopting my present pup, Jerry, in January 2015. Having a 45-pound pit bull in the home has given me a number of sensible expertise. Thankfully he is not an escape artist, and the one time he did get out, I discovered him ready patiently within the entrance yard.

I’ve additionally been professionally reviewing devices for greater than six years, together with authoring Wirecutter’s information to the best Bluetooth trackers, a considerably related class.

Who that is for

A GPS pet tracker, love most emergency gear, is one thing you hope you by no means have to make use of. The system makes use of an embedded GPS transponder in addition to mobile information alerts to speak your pet’s location at a given time. The concept is that in case your pet escapes, you will obtain a notification by way of an app, have the power to trace its location in actual time, and be safely reunited. These trackers are primarily for individuals who know their pet is more likely to get out and get misplaced, moderately than the typical pet proprietor. You may also love a pet tracker when you’ve got an outside pet (a cat, probably) and also you’d choose to maintain tabs on its adventures all through the day.

Because these trackers use GPS, they’re much extra correct than Bluetooth trackers, which talk their location provided that they’re inside Bluetooth vary of your cellphone, or if another person working on the identical tracker ecosystem occurs to wander previous.

Some of those trackers additionally monitor your pet’s exercise, a lot love a fitness tracker an individual may put on. That’s a high quality function to have, and one thing you could discover helpful, however we centered solely on the monitoring facet.

How we picked

The GPS pet trackers we examined. Photo: Michael Hession

Few GPS pet trackers can be found proper now, and the gathering of fashions truly value testing is even smaller. After combing by way of websites love Amazon and Chewy, and in search of critiques of such units, we discovered a handful value contemplating. From there, we dismissed trackers that relied on T-Mobile’s 2G community moderately than AT&T’s 3G community (all of them work on older-generation GSM networks). While information velocity is not a major concern with these units, T-Mobile’s community is solely smaller than AT&T’s—once you’re coping with a difficulty love discovering your pet, you need the most important doable community. We eradicated one other tracker primarily based on its excessive preliminary value and low proprietor rankings. That left us with 4 fashions to check.

How we examined

GPS trackers for pets

Our trustworthy testing pup, Jerry. Photo: Nick Guy

A superb pet tracker ought to be straightforward to arrange and should keep in your pet, so we began by evaluating the {hardware} itself. We checked out how big every tracker was, how straightforward it was to connect securely to a canine’s collar, and if it had any energy controls to fret about. Then we went by way of the setup course of with every mannequin, guaranteeing there have been no main hurdles in getting it to work.

But as a result of the first concern with GPS pet trackers is whether or not they’re efficient at letting you discover your pets, that is the place we centered our testing efforts. All the trackers we examined supported some form of “safe zone,” primarily based on sustaining a connection to a specific Wi-Fi community or base station, or staying inside an outlined space. When the trackers are on this zone, they do not activate their GPS radio, saving important battery life. We examined to see how lengthy every tracker lasted on a cost whereas inside a protected zone, which revealed the best-case-scenario determine—how lengthy the battery will final when your pet would not depart the home.

To see how shortly and precisely every tracker was in a position to replace its location, we despatched the trackers on a 35-mile bike experience in upstate New York, periodically checking the place the trackers had been throughout the journey. At the tip of the experience, we additionally famous the remaining battery life, gaining an concept of how lengthy a tracker could final on an escaped pet.

GPS trackers for pets

The Paby (left), Tractive (heart), and Whistle (proper) apps. Screenshots: Nick Guy

Finally, we wandered round Manhattan to 5 totally different places with the trackers in tow. At every cease, we turned off Bluetooth and Wi-Fi on our check cellphone (to ensure the trackers weren’t making a direct reference to the cellphone, however moderately counting on their 3G and GPS radios to speak their place). We recorded each how correct every tracker’s reported places had been and the way shortly every tracker’s companion smartphone app up to date.

Our decide: Whistle Three GPS Pet Tracker & Activity Monitor

If you are involved about your pet getting away and also you desire a device that can assist you extra simply discover it, the best choice is the Whistle 3 GPS Pet Tracker & Activity Monitor. This tracker is as correct as any mannequin we examined, shortly transmitting its GPS sign again to your cellphone. It lasts longer on a cost than any of the opposite contenders we tried, its {hardware} design is one of the best by an extended shot, and its smartphone software program is equally effectively thought out.

The most vital facet of any of those trackers is the power to search out your pet’s location, and to take action shortly and repeatedly, because it is likely to be on the transfer. While the Whistle Three did not stand head and shoulders above the remainder of the pack on this regard, it did tie for one of the best. Throughout our checks, we had been in a position to get the tracker’s location inside a matter of seconds, and that reported location was all the time shut sufficient to the precise location that we would be able to discover our pet simply. But as with pulling up Maps in your cellphone, the accuracy can shift attributable to mobile phone protection, big buildings, and different elements outdoors of your management. We particularly love that the Whistle 3’s smartphone app flashes you not solely the place the tracker is but additionally the place you might be in relation to it, which is useful in case you’re looking for your pet in an unfamiliar space. The app additionally has a button to refresh the situation manually, one thing different trackers’ apps lack.

Where the Whistle Three most units itself other than different fashions is in battery life. When we left the Whistle Three undisturbed inside a house Wi-Fi protected zone, it did not simply last more than every other tracker—it even surpassed the period of time we had allotted for the check. Thirteen days into the check, and 6 days after the next-longest battery gave out, the Whistle 3’s battery was nonetheless at 69 p.c.

In our bike-ride check, the Whistle Three carried out in addition to the three different trackers in location reporting, nevertheless it once more bested the competitors in battery life. We eliminated all 4 from their charging stations at 8:21 a.m., and at 8:00 p.m. the Whistle Three reported 78 p.c of full cost, with the next-closest competitor (the Tractive) at 65 p.c. Having a longer-lasting battery is vital, as a result of it means you must cost the system much less continuously and you’ve got an extended window to search out your pet if it will get misplaced. There’s additionally the mixture of the 2: Unlike with a smartphone, the place you possibly can wait to cost your handset till it is nearly useless, you must recharge a tracker effectively earlier than the battery is low so you may have time to search out your wandering pet.

The Whistle Three additionally has one of the best bodily design of any pet tracker we examined. It’s the lightest we examined at slightly below an oz, which for a tiny cat may make an actual distinction in consolation. At 1.four inches large by 1.2 inches tall, it isn’t too obtrusive. Whistle says the tracker is designed for pets heavier than Eight kilos, and whereas we do not assume tiny animals may have points with the burden of the tracker, its bulk could show extra irritating for a toy canine or a cat. The collar mount has a sturdy band that holds it securely—even on tiny collars—although Whistle recommends a collar no less than 1 inch large. (We had one thing of a tough time getting the band off to place the mount on the collar, however we might moderately have or not it’s a tiny troublesome to placed on and take off if meaning it is much less more likely to fall off.) The Whistle Three itself then securely snaps into the mount with a twist. It will not come off except you maintain down a spring-loaded button and twist 1 / 4 flip, an motion your opposable-thumb-lacking companion is unlikely to take purposefully or by accident. The Whistle Three can also be rated IP67, that means it is dust-tight and might survive being immersed in as much as a meter of water. If your canine will get out and swims by way of a river, the Whistle Three will nonetheless work.

GPS trackers for pets

The band that holds the Whistle 3’s mount to the collar is sturdy and never notably straightforward to take away, which is an efficient factor. Photo: Michael Hession

The Whistle 3’s charging base makes use of the identical attachment system to carry the tracker in place, save for the button to launch it. We love this safe mount, particularly in contrast with competing trackers that may simply dislodge from their chargers or be ambiguous about their charging state.

Whistle’s app (for iOS and Android) is among the many best to make use of. At the forefront is an important factor: your pet’s location. A tray on the backside of the display screen shows the present battery life, the space from dwelling, and when the situation final up to date. When your pet is misplaced, the app presents an choice to replace the situation manually proper on the map, in addition to a monitoring mode that updates the situation each 90 seconds. The app additionally has an exercise panel that tracks how a lot train your pet has gotten, in addition to a display screen that allows you to arrange extra protected zones or alter the unique zone.

Like most competing trackers, the Whistle Three requires a 3G service plan. You can select to pay $10 a month with no dedication, or save by paying for a 12 months ($100) and even two ($170) prematurely. That’s dearer than the plans for another trackers, which signifies that some pricier fashions are literally a bit inexpensive to personal over, say, two years, however contemplating the Whistle 3’s efficiency, we predict it is value it.

Few websites evaluate pet trackers, however the Whistle Three is the recipient of PCMag’s Editors’ Choice designation for its “strong combination of performance and price,” with the publication citing lengthy battery life and nice {hardware}.

Flaws however not dealbreakers

Like all GPS pet trackers, the Whistle Three is restricted by its battery life and its entry to a mobile community. If your pet will get out when the battery occurs to be low, or in an space with poor AT&T protection, your possibilities of discovering Fido lower drastically. None of those trackers, not even the Whistle 3, can declare to be a panacea for pet escapes. Consider one as an additional line of protection which will assist you in a worst-case situation.

All the trackers we examined are additionally fairly chunky, that means they may not be a fantastic match for cats or toy canines who could not tolerate having such a (comparatively) large system across the neck. Whistle recommends its trackers for pets Eight kilos and bigger.

Despite its title, the Whistle is completely silent. Unlike with the Link AKC and Paby trackers we tested, or Bluetooth trackers, you possibly can’t use the app to set off a sound that can assist you discover your pet hiding within the underbrush.

Two Wirecutter writers testing the Whistle Three discovered the setup course of to be a trouble, with the app crashing a number of occasions. Eventually, every tester was in a position to full the steps and was pleased with the precise service supplied, however some individuals could also be turned off by this preliminary interplay.

In considered one of our check places in Manhattan, the Whistle Three was unable to replace its location. We do not know the precise cause it did not replace, however we had no points in subsequent trials. Other trackers had extra extreme or extra extended service interruptions in our testing, as we note in the Competition section.

What a couple of Tile or different Bluetooth tracker?

A Bluetooth tracker could appear interesting for pet monitoring. A Tile Mate, for instance, prices lower than half the worth of even the most cost effective of those GPS pet trackers, and you do not have to pay an ongoing subscription price. Battery life is roughly a 12 months, not days. A Tile is smaller than any of the pet trackers we examined, and the Tile app offers an expertise just like that of the Whistle app. If you are in an city space with an honest variety of different Tile homeowners, the monitoring might be pretty correct.

The drawback is {that a} Tile or different Bluetooth tracker would assist you discover your pet provided that you are very near your pet, or if another person who makes use of that model of tracker—and thus is a part of that tracker’s crowd-finding system—may be very shut. And with the latter, there’s often a delay earlier than you get a notification, at which level your pet could also be lengthy gone. At finest, the crowd-finding function of a Bluetooth tracker can provide you an concept of the final space your pet is (or was) in.

A Bluetooth tracker could work in the proper situation. But in case you’re involved about discovering an escaped pet, we predict the peace of thoughts a GPS tracker presents is value the additional value, as substantial as it might be.

What to stay up for

Whistle launched two new GPS pet trackers: the Whistle Go and Whistle Go Explore. The Whistle Go’s battery lasts for as much as 10 days, whereas the Whistle Go Explore can run for as much as 20 days. Both variations supply dwell monitoring, versus the Whistle 3’s 60-second interval. We’ll replace this information with our outcomes after we’ve completed testing.

The competitors

The Paby 3G GPS Pet Tracker & Activity Monitor was our runner-up decide, nevertheless it’s since been discontinued. It was quick and correct at telling you your pet’s location, however its battery did not final almost so long as our high decide’s. Its design additionally appeared cheaper and felt extra plasticky.

The Link AKC Smart Collar is probably the nicest trying of the tracker fashions we examined, however sadly that is all it has going for it. With this mannequin’s American Kennel Club branding, we anticipated higher efficiency, however we ended up disenchanted. The Link AKC is the costliest tracker that requires a service plan, at present coming in at about $100 greater than the competitors earlier than you issue within the $10 month-to-month price (one- or two-year plans supply a less expensive charge). Part of this value is definitely as a result of leather-based canine collar included within the equipment. The collar is obtainable in 4 sizes, and the corporate will exchange the collar without cost in case your canine grows out of it. The tracker itself can also be the most important we examined, and Link AKC representatives informed us it is particularly to be used with canines weighing 15 kilos or extra. Cats needn’t apply.

In our battery testing, the Link AKC collar was useless inside two days on a house Wi-Fi community. Rather than displaying the proportion cost left, the app flashes battery stage in one-quarter increments, which is not very helpful. During our bike-ride check, the Link AKC collar merely did not decide up a sign, so at no level may we observe the place it was or examine its monitoring towards the others. And due to the shortage of a granular battery indicator, we could not inform precisely how a lot battery remained on the finish, nevertheless it was within the pink, suggesting it had lower than 25 p.c. (Link AKC recommends charging the collar each evening alongside your cellphone on the included base station, however given our outcomes, we’re undecided even a full cost could be sufficient to make it by way of a “lost day”—to not point out in case your pet is misplaced for longer (or in case your canine runs off in the midst of the evening). PCMag had a better experience with the Link AKC collar, going as far as to say the system “comes so close to being a dream tracker in many ways.” But even when the monitoring had labored completely, the dimensions, worth, and battery life put this one out of the competitors. (As we had been getting ready this information for publication, the corporate knowledgeable us of an upcoming firmware replace with “improved Bluetooth connectivity and faster, more accurate GPS tracking.” But, once more, the problems we famous are too problematic for us to suggest this tracker, even when the enhancements are important.)

The Tractive GPS Pet Tracker was unreliable in our checks. During our bike experience, it did not replace for a number of hours, and we discovered that it took longer to supply its location than the opposite trackers whereas travelling by way of Manhattan. And as a result of it presents no choice to replace the place manually, you are on the whim of when the app chooses (or is in a position) to take action. The Tractive additionally has the least secure-feeling clip, a plastic bracket that feels love it may get knocked off fairly simply.

We thought of testing the Nuzzle pet exercise and GPS tracker. It’s the one tracker that does not require a month-to-month service plan, however that value is front-loaded into the worth of the system itself, which is the costliest of any we discovered. The present evaluate scores on Amazon are additionally considerably decrease than these of every other tracker we thought of, with a majority giving the Nuzzle just one star. At this writing, the Nuzzle has gone out of inventory on Amazon and the worth has shot up even greater, which in our expertise often is not an excellent signal; it’s nonetheless accessible at its official retail worth from Nuzzle’s web site.

This information could have been up to date by Wirecutter. To see the present advice, please go here.

When readers select to purchase Wirecutter’s independently chosen editorial picks, Wirecutter and Engadget could earn affiliate commissions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *